I have waited to put pen to paper after being part of the sell-out crowd at Suncorp who witnessed the Kiwis become the New World Champions. The Australians played poorly, but they were clearly frustrated by the bewildering decisions made by Ashley Klein and Video Ref Steve Ganson. From the country that gave us Russell Smith, the decision making was inconsistent with every dodgy call going against the Australians.
Firstly we saw a try awarded to the Kiwis when Benji Marshall lost the ball forward, to have it picked up and scored. The replay showed an the tackle attempt coming into contact with the ball, but then Marshal regained the ball and was the last touch as it came flying out of his hands. In under 8's and every level of the game, knock-on. In the Joke of a World Cup- Try to the Kiwis.
Klein allowed to much latitude in the rucks and off-side. Australia were penalised, the Kiwis weren't. Australia were penalised for a high shot. The Kiwis weren't. At one stage in the first half, Lockyer was hit high in the tackle, and then as he got up to play the ball was the victim of a second shove. Klein just stood there with his hand up stating play the ball, 5th tackle.
A massive call was made with an awarding of a penalty try to New Zealand. A kick that bounced awkardly for Joel Monaghan, caused him to miss the ball and tackle the advancing Lance Ohaia off the ball. Ganson awarded a penalty try, even with the fact that Ohaia still had to beat Billy Slater to the ball, as Jonathon Thurston. Replays showed that the ball bounced into Slaters hands, meaning Ohaia had to get to the ball before it bounced. The awarding of a penalty try can ONLY be made when IF a CERTAIN try was stopped due to an illegal play. This try was far from certain. The call should have been Penalty NZ, Monaghan in the bin.
The Australians were penalised again soon after for driving the Kiwis back behind their try-line. Aside from the fact that the NZ player's was tackled swiftly and was into the end zone within a couple of seconds by the original tacklers. Klein alledgly called held. Compare with the David Williams being driven out, when momentum was clearly stopped, additional tackles drove in, Williams legs were lifted off the ground and carried over the sideline. POOR FORM KLEIN.
The final try was simply a joke. Even the most elementry referee would have seen at least two kiwis knock-ons during this play. But hang on, this is the JOKE World Cup. Try New Zealand.
It is a shame that this game debate will be dominated by the refereeing decisions. They were poor and have now led themselves to consipracy theories of the RLWC committee had somehow planned this. Did the refs have money on the Kiwis? I don't believe either. Klein and Ganson were simply incompetant and ruined a great game.
Australia on their part contributed to the game with some stupid play. They always appeared set on winning the game on the one tackle. The Billy Slater brain explosion gifting a try to Benji Marshall was the biggest case in point, but Williams courting the sideline was another. Dropped balls from Fitzgibbon in dire situations led again to pressure for the Aussies.
The Australian forward pack was ineffective and missed Price badly. Watmoungh was outclassed, Petro and Fitzy have played their last tests. Cam Smith was slow and looked disinterested. Kite was poor. LaFranchi, Stewart and Gallon at last had a go. In the backs, Monaghan was poor, Inglis rarely sighted, Folou well marked, Slater played his worst game of 2008, JT was poor and the Australians looked disorganised. Darren Lockyer was adequate and didn't deserve the Man of the Match award. The best player for the Kiwis wore pink.
AT the end of the day, many were saying this was one of the great Australian teams. It is easy to look good when beating sides by big scores. Under pressure from the incompetant refs and a refreshed Kiwis NO-ONE stood up to be counted. You could not imagine that from some of the truly great Australian sides from 1982, 1986, 1990 and 1994. This side was a Ricky Shell. It wasn't the best side picked. Simple
Many will say this is a great shot in the arm for the international game. I just think it lends itself as a joke with all the poor decisions that impacted the Australians. It will always be remembered for the poor officials.This World Cup did not need a contrived result. This World Cup highlighted the best of the other nations. It brought international football outside of the big names, Back and back in a big way. Unfortunately it ended in a joke.