The Indigenous All-Stars won the inaugural NRL All-Stars game 16-12, with two Jonathon Thurston Conversions the difference. The game was played with an intensity that surprised many, but from those within the Indigenous camp didn't.
Inspired by deed by the like of Loinel Morgan (first ever Indigenous Kangaroo) and stories of tribal warfare, and spurred on by a large majority of the crowd, the Indigenous team played with greater passion and commitment and deserved their win.
The first game has been played and the merits of the game will now be debated. We saw two major injuries with Darren Lockyer and Kurt Gidley likely to miss opening rounds of the season proper. Travis Waddell was knocked out and will need some rehabilitation. Many other likely injuries will be glossed over in coming weeks, as the match was intense enough to create.
Doubts must be cast also on the future of the game, due to the high level of dropouts that occurred preceding it. While clubs publicly praised the concept, it would appear that behind the scenes there may have been some dissent. This is likely to increase with the injuries that have occurred. Additionally, the Indigenous camp banished Justin Hodges due to his non-commitment to the game, which flies in the face of his public comments as well as the attitude of the vast majority of the squad.
The addition of the trial rule, the double try, was a joke. This MUST never be seen on a rugby league field again!!!!
Personally, I feel this game should not be played as our opening game. Much was spoken about reconciliation and the like on the night, I believe this game has a greater capacity to divide. It didn't last night. We saw a good natured crowd, with the passion and cheering purely one-sided. You might have thought the NRL All-Stars should have won and that is who you were cheering for, but the crowd didn't form an emotional attachment with the NRL. Emotion was ONLY evident in the cheering of the Indigenous team. And personally, I don't think most people really cared who won, they came for the entertainment and potentially the novelty, there were others for who it meant everything. This is where the potential divide and ugliness came in.
In contradiction, this game actually needs that emotion to survive. Without it, it becomes a meaningless clash. So we fuel the viability of this game through emotions based on race. Doesn't sound like reconciliation to me????? I love Preston Campbell, but I don't think his original idea was to play the NRL All-Stars. Maybe more in line with taking on other Pacific Indigenous tribes.
I will refer to an earlier article from THEFOOTY.com and again state, that this game should be played as the week lead-in to the Grand Final after giving the grand final qualifiers a fortnight break before the big game. This is an ideal time, when season commitments for most players have finished.
I am confident also that players like Ben Jones, are 100% proud of whatever tribal culture they possess. Not sure if his selection does anything for the credibility of the game, however.